I have a weakness for Emily Yoffe who writes as Dear Prudence over at Slate, and I usually find something to disagree with in her “advice”, but she really takes the cake in today’s column! Seems like Prudie has been hitting the haterade a little hard these days.
http://judgybitch.com/2013/01/01/manners-i-wish-this-bitch-would-get-some/
Here’s the first letter:
I’m a 28-year-old male and have a 4-year-old daughter with my partner of nine years (we’re not married but completely committed). My daughter was not planned and I had serious reservations about having a child at such a young age, but there’s a lot of love in our family and everything has worked out. But since taking a new job several months ago, I’ve started feeling differently. All of my co-workers are young and I’ve made a few good friends, but I often have to decline invitations to events I’d really like to attend because of my family obligations, or because I can’t afford it. I’m the only one with a full plate of adult responsibilities, including supporting my partner, who is an artist and doesn’t bring home a paycheck every week. So I have to say no to joining them on road trips or at exclusive restaurants, because my weekend consists of toddler birthday parties and visits to the playground. It’s making me rueful that I’ve missed my 20s and worried I will wind up bitter no matter how much I love my family. How do I get out of this funk and regain happiness with my circumstances, and how do I face my co-workers every day when they’re a constant reminder of what I’m missing?
-Longing for Lost Youth
Okay, so Prudie starts off her answer by pointing out that while the letter writer has jumped the gun on the having kids stage of life, sooner or later most of his co-workers will catch up with him, and he can have a good chuckle at their bleary eyed shock when they find out babies aren’t really fond of the whole “sleep for eight hours on a corporate schedule” thing and then blissfully enjoy sleeping through the night.
Fair enough. That’s what I would have answered, too. You get your twenties or your forties, and quite frankly, there’s something rather nice about having the energy to take care of your children because you had them young enough, and knowing that by the time they are off to college, you yourself will still be young enough to do all those things you missed out on when you were younger.
Not to mention that couples who have their children while still relatively young are unlikely to find themselves facing the utter heartbreak of “Oops! We left it too long and the eggs done flew the coop!” Infertility is a brutal sorrow, and the couples we know who decided that material possessions and fabulous experiences were far more important than children are now left with the bitterness of an album full of great vacation pics and a nursery that will never hold anything more than dreams.
But rather than point out all that, Prudie goes off onto a rant about how his lazy-ass partner better ruck up and start earning some cash, mostly to protect herself from the inevitable day when the letter writer decides to leave his child to starve in the gutters.
Now that you have a child, you two need to be more deliberate about what you want out of life. It’s fine if your child is an only, but if you want to expand your family, that’s a discussion you should be having. Being an artist can be a dream career, but since your partner is not make a living at it, it’s time she applied her skills to more remunerative endeavors, especially as your daughter gets ready for full-time schooling. If something happens to you, your partner will be completely financially vulnerable.
Oh, it’s time she applied her skills to more remunerative endeavors, is it?
Fuck you, Prudie.
And if by “something might happen to you” Prudie meant the letter writer might die or become disabled, she might have suggested the precaution of some insurance policies. The implication is that the woman is vulnerable simply by virtue of being dependent on a man. Because you know men, right? There’s nothing they enjoy more than walking off into the sunset and leaving a beloved child to suffer wretched poverty and a broken heart.
Rather than expressing gratitude for a man who is supporting his family and allowing the woman to whom he is committed to pursue her artistic dreams, Prudie instead insults both of them by casting her as a leech and him as someone not to be relied on.
Nice.
And it gets better!
Here is another letter:
My husband’s friend is a perpetual bachelor. He dates a girl for a few months, introduces her around, brings her to group functions, etc., and then dumps her once it has gotten too serious. Because the friend and my husband are close, I become the new best friend for the girlfriend du jour during camping trips, double dates, sports games, and happy hours with our group. The bachelor is charming and has the women believing everything is perfect until the breakup blindside. Then they are devastated and I end up having to deal with tearful phone calls and get-togethers while they ask me what went wrong. The most recent breakup involved a fragile woman with no close friends or family in town. I felt rude for not returning all the frantic calls and texts of this woman, but I’m frustrated that this draining duty always seems to fall on me. I’ve talked to the bachelor about it, and he says no one is forcing me to become friends with his girlfriends. That’s true, but it’s hard not to act like a decent human being to these women. How can I avoid this pitfall in the future?
—Sick of the Bachelor
A charming man dates women, introduces them to his social circle and has a habit of NOT stringing them along endlessly when he discovers they are not The One. If the ladies in question are “blindsided” by the breakup, that strongly suggests that no lengthy period of playing games and putting up with squabbles and quarrels simply to get as much sex out of each relationship as possible is going on.
Bachelor dates women, and the minute he realizes he’s not with the right one, he breaks it off.
I dunno. Seems to me to be EXACTLY how dating should happen. When you know the relationship is not going to work out, put an end to it and move on.
What does Prudie think?
As was said of one character on King of the Hill, “He’s going to make some woman very happy. Until he makes her very sad.” You’ve talked to the bachelor about this problem, but I think you should bring this up with your husband. I hope by this point he’s getting a little squeamish about his friend’s manipulative and even sadistic pattern, and is willing to have a frank discussion. Whatever happens, you could also request your husband see the bachelor alone for lunch more often, for example, and have fewer group outings with him and his latest. But if inevitably there will be occasions when you’re with the new Patsy, I think you should give it to her straight. Do that thing where women go off to the bathroom in pairs. While there, as soon as she makes some noises about what a great guy Dick is, let her know he’s a cad. Explain you’ve been through this with endless women. He charms and misleads them and when they think things are going somewhere, he dumps them. That’s how he gets his thrills. Say you’re being so blunt because you just can’t stand to nurse anyone else through the inevitable. She’ll probably dismiss you because she knows this time it’s different. She might even report what you said back to Dick. If he brings it up with you, just tell him you look forward to being proven wrong.
Let’s take this apart, shall we?
As was said of one character on King of the Hill, “He’s going to make some woman very happy. Until he makes her very sad.”
Oh goodie. Let’s begin with a reference to a very popular, very funny show about god-fearin’ ‘Murrican trash! We know what Prudie thinks of this whole crew right off the bat.
You’ve talked to the bachelor about this problem, but I think you should bring this up with your husband. I hope by this point he’s getting a little squeamish about his friend’s manipulative and even sadistic pattern, and is willing to have a frank discussion.
Manipulative and sadistic. Manipulative and sadistic? Are you fucking kidding me? Nope, nope, nope. Stringing women you have ZERO intention of pursuing a serious relationship with is manipulative and sadistic. Keeping the booty call on stand-by while you scout for new talent is manipulative and sadistic. Letting someone believe there is potential when there is NOT is manipulative and sadistic.
Finding a long series of women inadequate is neither of those things, but it sure pisses Prudie off, doesn’t it? It’s almost like the Bachelor is working his way through some women who suck, and he refuses to settle.
What an asshole!
Whatever happens, you could also request your husband see the bachelor alone for lunch more often, for example, and have fewer group outings with him and his latest.
Oh, yes. Interfere with your husband’s relationship with his friends. Make him really uncomfortable and start determining where, when and under what circumstances he is allowed to see his friend. And if hubby doesn’t agree, you can always ground him or take away his phone privileges.
Excellent advice, Prudie. I’m sure her husband will be thrilled.
But if inevitably there will be occasions when you’re with the new Patsy, I think you should give it to her straight. Do that thing where women go off to the bathroom in pairs. While there, as soon as she makes some noises about what a great guy Dick is, let her know he’s a cad. Explain you’ve been through this with endless women. He charms and misleads them and when they think things are going somewhere, he dumps them. That’s how he gets his thrills. Say you’re being so blunt because you just can’t stand to nurse anyone else through the inevitable.
Wow.
No.
Just no.
Do not do this.
First of all, you are betraying your husband by betraying his friend. Why the fuck should you care what happens to the Bachelor’s women? Where do your loyalties lie? With other women deemed unacceptable? You will stab your both your husband and his friend in the back to protect some woman that means nothing to you in the long run?
I can’t believe Prudie would suggest this. And how does she know that the Bachelor gets his thrills by dumping women? How does she know he is a cad? And what is a cad anyways?
cad
/kad/
Noun
A man who behaves dishonorably, esp. toward a woman.
Synonyms
scoundrel – boor – scamp
Again, how is it dishonorable to dump women you are no longer interested in? Prudie just can’t wrap her mind around the fact that lots of women are simply not worth a man’s time.
I wonder what the Bachelor does for a living? How exactly does he find all these women? Who wants to bet he has a fairly high social status in his group? A good income? A bit of nice property? Speculation, but no amount of screaming in the world is going to change the fact that men tend to value beauty and women value status. If Bachelor has women lined up, it’s a pretty safe bet that he has something that women value.
And who is behaving dishonorably here, again?
She’ll probably dismiss you because she knows this time it’s different. She might even report what you said back to Dick. If he brings it up with you, just tell him you look forward to being proven wrong.
She MIGHT report what you said back to Dick? Oh, honey, she most certainly WILL. And no, you should not respond with some smug cunty statement like “I look forward to being proven wrong”. All you are doing is making it clear that YOU think Dick the Bachelor IS a dick, and again, you are not going to please your husband or Dick by insulting him to his face.
You might just get your husband wondering why HE wasn’t a little more picky.
Here is what Prudie should have said:
Dick’s romantic life is really none of your business, and as an adult, you should assume he knows what he is doing and is perfectly happy with how his relationships work. If and when discarded ladies text or call you, you respond with this:
I’m really sorry things didn’t work out, but I am not the person you should be talking to.
I’m really sorry things didn’t work out, but I am not the person you should be talking to.
I’m really sorry things didn’t work out, but I am not the person you should be talking to.
I’m really sorry things didn’t work out, but I am not the person you should be talking to.
Repeat until she gets it. Refuse to comment on anyone’s love life but your own. And as an aside, you should make a special effort to welcome any woman Dick decides to introduce you to. It’s actually a compliment. He wants to see how the women he dates interact with the people he loves most, and whose company he values.
I hope Sick of the Bachelor ignores Prudie and decides that Bachelor really is capable of handling his own affairs. She will be making a big mistake to interfere with her husband’s friendship and the Bachelor’s love life.
You know, even if I have this dead wrong, and the Bachelor IS the kind of guy who is thrilled by the chase and loses all interest once it is over, the letter writer should STILL back the Bachelor. You never takes side against your husband’s friends. Not ever.
The people we marry come to us in a web of relationships, and it is not up to us to decide on our partner’s behalf which friends are acceptable and which are not. I wouldn’t necessarily pick all my husband’s friends as my own, and some of my friends grate on his nerves, too.
I have, in fact, let friendships lapse because I could see that Mr. JB wasn’t particularly enamored of the friend in question. But that was MY decision. I am the one who stopped to consider if his dislike was grounded in any facts, and when I discovered that he had a REASON to dislike the person, I chose to let them go.
Because I know where my loyalties lie.
And that’s what it comes down to. Be loyal. Anything less is hard to forgive.
I place an enormous premium on loyalty. If someone betrays me, I can forgive them rationally, but emotionally I have found it impossible to do so.
Richard E. Grant
And don’t listen to Dear Prudence. Her advice sucks.
Lots of love,
JB